Northern New Jersey (973) 427-8164

Proudly veteran-owned

Appraisal assignment

Using an appraisal to cancel PMI in New Jersey

An appraisal can end a monthly premium — but only on terms your servicer sets, and only if they will look at one you paid for.

(973) 427-8164 Other ways to reach me

The call that comes before the appraisal

This is the assignment where owners most often pay me for a document that never had a chance of working, so I would rather lose the job than have that happen. Make one phone call first.

Two rights you already have, and neither needs me

Federal law hands every borrower with private mortgage insurance two protections, and both are calculated on the property’s original value — what it was worth the day you bought it, not what it is worth now.

  • The premium terminates automatically once the balance reaches 78% of that original value.
  • You can request cancellation at 80% of the same figure.

Both are arithmetic on your loan schedule. No appraisal is involved in either, and no appraiser should be charging you for one.

What appreciation actually triggers

Cancelling because the house has gone up is not one of those rights. It is a separate process, run under your servicer’s policy and the rules of whoever owns the loan, and they set the terms — including whether a valuation you paid for counts for anything.

So before commissioning a report from me or from anyone:

  1. Do you cancel on current value? Some servicers simply do not.
  2. What LTV, and what seasoning? On conventional loans under Fannie Mae’s rules this generally means two years at 75%, or five years at 80%. Under two years, expect to need documented improvements of real substance.
  3. Will you accept an appraisal I commission? Ask this one last and listen carefully. A number of servicers will only read a valuation they ordered from their own panel, which makes yours worthless to them and to you.

Get the answers in writing. A note in a servicing portal is worth more than a recollection of a phone call when somebody later disputes what was agreed.

Then do the arithmetic

A premium around here commonly runs between $80 and $250 a month, depending on loan size, original loan-to-value and credit profile.

Set your figure against the fee I quote you. At the middle of that range the payback lands in months and everything after it stays in your pocket. That is a genuinely good trade — provided the value clears.

Where it looks marginal, the honest advice is to wait. A report that lands two percentage points under the threshold is a real cost with nothing on the other side of it, and the conclusion will not be nudged to make the number. If it would move for you it would move against you, and then it is worth nothing to anybody.

If the loan is FHA

Then this route is usually closed, and it is worth checking before anything else.

FHA mortgage insurance is not private mortgage insurance, whatever the monthly line on your statement is labelled. For loans endorsed on or after 3 June 2013 at a high original loan-to-value, the premium runs for the life of the loan and no appraisal will remove it. The way out is generally refinancing into a conventional loan — a conversation to have with a lender.

Why it keeps coming up in these counties

A large share of purchases across Passaic, Bergen, Essex and Hudson between 2016 and 2021 were made with less than 20% down. What happened to values afterwards carried many of those owners past their equity threshold years ahead of where the schedule would have taken them.

Plenty are still paying, for the ordinary reason that nobody rereads a mortgage statement that has not changed. Waterfront condominium owners in Hudson County are the clearest case of it.

What you receive

A written appraisal with a current effective date, presented in whatever form the servicer specified, carrying a signed USPAP certification.

It goes to you, and directly to the servicer if you instruct me in writing to send it. The fee and the turnaround are confirmed before anything starts.

New Jersey specifics

  • A great many purchases across Passaic, Bergen, Essex and Hudson between 2016 and 2021 were made with less than 20% down, and the years that followed moved values faster than any amortisation schedule would have.
  • Condominium owners in Hudson County are the group most likely to be carrying a premium they no longer need, because the run-up along the waterfront was steep and a mortgage statement that never changes is a statement nobody rereads.

What you receive

  • An appraisal with a current effective date
  • The conclusion presented in the form your servicer told you they accept
  • Signed USPAP certification
  • Delivery to you, and direct to the servicer if you instruct me in writing

What I need from you

  • The servicer's cancellation requirements, in writing
  • Your origination date and the original purchase price or appraised value
  • The current principal balance
  • Interior access

Speak to the appraiser

Call about a pmi removal appraisal

Most of this is quicker said than written. Give me the address, what the appraisal has to do, and the date you are working to — a fee and an inspection date come back on the call rather than in a form response two days later.

Worth mentioning: Who is ordering it, and whether a lender or a servicer has already told you what they will accept. That answer decides whether you should be commissioning anything at all.

(973) 427-8164
Mon–Fri, by appointment
Direct line

Rather write? vinnymel@verizon.net — answered within one business day.

FAQ

Common questions

Will an appraisal definitely get my PMI removed?

No. Anyone who tells you otherwise is selling something. Federal law gives you two rights and neither one involves an appraisal: automatic termination once the balance reaches 78% of the property's original value, and cancellation on request at 80% of that same original value. Both are arithmetic on your loan. Cancelling because the house appreciated is a separate process that your servicer controls, and their rules decide whether an appraisal counts for anything at all.

What exactly should I ask the servicer?

Three things, and get the answers in writing. Do you cancel on current value? What loan-to-value and how much seasoning do you require? And will you accept an appraisal I commission, or must it come from your own panel? The third question is the one that costs people money, because a fair number of servicers will only look at a valuation they ordered.

What thresholds are normal?

On conventional loans following Fannie Mae's servicing rules, cancelling on current value generally means a loan at least two years old at no more than 75% LTV, or at least five years old at no more than 80%. Under two years, documented improvements of real substance are generally needed. Freddie Mac's approach is comparable. Which set governs depends on who owns your loan, which is not always who sends the statement — so confirm rather than assume.

Ours is an FHA loan. Same thing?

No, and this is where most of the wasted money goes. FHA mortgage insurance is a different product from private mortgage insurance whatever the line on the statement looks like, and for loans endorsed on or after 3 June 2013 at a high original loan-to-value the premium runs for the life of the loan. No appraisal shifts it. The exit is generally a refinance into a conventional loan, which is a conversation for a lender and not for me.

Is the fee worth it?

Do the arithmetic before you spend anything. A premium in this part of the state commonly falls somewhere between $80 and $250 a month depending on loan size, original LTV and credit profile. Set that against the fee I quote you and the payback is usually measured in months. That is a good trade when the value clears, and a straight loss when it does not, which is the entire reason for the screening questions.

What happens if the value comes in short?

It comes in short and it stays there. The conclusion reports what the evidence supports; it does not get adjusted upward to clear somebody's threshold, and an appraiser who would do that for you would do it against you. Finding out in advance that you are close to the line is exactly what the phone call is for.

Sources for the figures on this page
  • HPA provides automatic termination at 78% LTV and borrower-requested cancellation at 80% LTV, both based on original value. Source: Homeowners Protection Act of 1998, 12 U.S.C. §4901 et seq.. Verified 2026-07-30.
  • Borrower-initiated termination on current value is permitted at 75% LTV or lower where the loan is between two and five years old, and at 80% or lower once it is more than five years old. Source: Fannie Mae Servicing Guide, borrower-initiated mortgage insurance termination. Verified 2026-07-30.
  • Duration of the FHA mortgage insurance premium on loans endorsed on or after 3 June 2013. Source: HUD Mortgagee Letter 2013-04. Verified 2026-07-30.

Next step

Two minutes on the phone settles most of this

Tell me what the number has to do and the date you are working to. Those two fix the effective date, the fee and the turnaround on the call — and where an appraisal is the wrong tool, or a free one would answer you just as well, that is what you will hear before anything is ordered.

(973) 427-8164 Other ways to reach me